So interesting Sinead, the Irish perspective on copyright is interesting, after all it is the location of one of the first copyright disputes, the copying of a manuscript by Colmcille caused a war, and resulted in his voluntary exile to Iona. 'To each cow, its calf' was the original verdict, which condems AI scraping training data two millenia later.
Sinead, goods which can be returned? So there is a specific offence under the road traffic act in Ireland for taking a car and say joy riding around. The intention according to law is not to permanently deprive the owner of his / her property. The offence is not considered to be one of theft but unauthorised taking. Now if the Gardai establish that the thief has taken the car and say filed off the engine number or changed the number plates these actions elevate ihe offence into the theft category. I'm wondering if its possibkecto apply a similar legal approach to the question of data? Not theft but an offence of unauthorised taking of data. Perhaps civil law is far more complicated?
So interesting Sinead, the Irish perspective on copyright is interesting, after all it is the location of one of the first copyright disputes, the copying of a manuscript by Colmcille caused a war, and resulted in his voluntary exile to Iona. 'To each cow, its calf' was the original verdict, which condems AI scraping training data two millenia later.
Sinead, goods which can be returned? So there is a specific offence under the road traffic act in Ireland for taking a car and say joy riding around. The intention according to law is not to permanently deprive the owner of his / her property. The offence is not considered to be one of theft but unauthorised taking. Now if the Gardai establish that the thief has taken the car and say filed off the engine number or changed the number plates these actions elevate ihe offence into the theft category. I'm wondering if its possibkecto apply a similar legal approach to the question of data? Not theft but an offence of unauthorised taking of data. Perhaps civil law is far more complicated?
Excellent worthy read to ponder ..
Evolved thinking … thank you Sinead